Blah Cross-examined
PRESIDING JUDGE: Good morning. Unless there are some preliminary matters I will remind the witness of his oath.
MR GRIFFITHS: Very well, your Honour.
PRESIDING JUDGE: Appearances appear to be as Friday, am
I correct, Mr Rapp?
MR RAPP: That is correct, your Honour.
PRESIDING JUDGE: Mr Griffiths, appearances as before?
MR GRIFFITHS: Your Honour, yes.
PRESIDING JUDGE: Mr Witness, I remind you again this
morning as I have done on other mornings that you took the oath
to tell the truth. That oath is still binding on you, you must
answer questions truthfully. Counsel for the Defence will have
some questions.
THE WITNESS: Your Honour.
WITNESS: MOSES ZEH BLAH [On former oath]
PRESIDING JUDGE: Please proceed, Mr Griffiths.
MR GRIFFITHS: May it please your Honour.
CROSS-EXAMINATION BY MR GRIFFITHS:
Q. Former President Blah, you didn't want to attend this Court
voluntarily, did you?
A. No. Yes, yes.
Q. You were quite happy to attend here and give evidence, were
you?
A. Yes, under condition that if I was subpoenaed I was going
to come to testify.
Q. You understand what a subpoena means, don't you? A
subpoena is normally used where a witness is reluctant to attend
court and so therefore the Court has to in effect force that
witness through threats to attend. You understand that, don't
you?
A. Yes, I understand that.
Q. So can I start with my first question again then, former
President, and it is this: You did not want to attend this Court
voluntarily, did you?
A. Yes, I wanted to attend, but it should be through subpoena
because what we said was that there were a lot of delays that
I had to go to the hospital and even to the hospital I went, the
things that I went through and if I was subpoenaed I will accept
to come to the Court.
Q. That is exactly the point I am trying to make, you see,
former President. That you were willing to attend on condition
that you were subpoenaed by the Court?
A. No, I was willing to attend the Court under condition and
that I did because there were a lot of delays, I had to go to the
hospital, I went for a press conference for over two days and
I came. I was willing to come and I was willing to come after
the last discussion.
Q. Let me approach the topic differently then. Were you at
any stage concerned that the people of Liberia might think if you
appeared at court voluntarily giving evidence against your former
comrade in arms and fellow President Charles Taylor that you had
betrayed him? Were you concerned about that?
A. Under condition again I will say this: That there were
just rumours all around that if I came to testify here I will be
killed, my people will be destroyed, my house will be burnt down
and those were intimidations on my part and that I did not mind,
so I came.
Q. I am trying to ask a very simple question.
A. Yes.
Q. Were you concerned that the people of Liberia might
consider it a betrayal if you came voluntarily to give evidence
against your former comrade in arms?
A. Well, how will I know if somebody was thinking about me as
such that I was coming to betray the former President? It was
not openly said to me. It was rumoured around and I had to
address the issue and I said that I was only coming to say the
truth and nothing but the truth.
Q. And it's right, is it not, that prior to attending at this
Court you held a press conference in Monrovia , didn't you?
A. Yes.
Q. I wonder, please, if the witness could be shown - and, your
Honours, I have prepared a bundle of documents which your Honours
should have before you. That is the bundle, your Honour, yes.
I am going to invite the witness's attention behind divider 1,
please, and page 1. You will see that here we have a press
report, dated 7 April 2008, and it reads as follows:
" Monrovia : Liberia 's former Vice-President Moses Blah said
Monday that he has been called to testify in the trial of
Charles Taylor, the first African leader to face an international
tribunal for war crimes. Blah said that the United Nations
Special Court for Sierra Leone , which is trying Liberia 's
ex-President Taylor in The Hague for his alleged key part in a
brutal civil war in the neighbouring country, had sent him a
Then it quotes you as saying:
"'I will speak the truth. That is why I am surprised that
some people are worried that there is the possibility of me
testifying' said Blah, who served as Vice-President under Taylor
and then briefly took over when he was ousted."
Can I pause there, please. Did you say that?
A. Yes, I said it.
Q. It continues:
"Blah said that he would tell the Court in The Hague about
the death of Sam Bockarie."
Then can I miss a couple of paragraphs and now can we go
over the page to page 2, please. This is another press report of
that press conference, dated 8 April 2008, and if I could invite
your attention, please, to the fourth paragraph from the bottom
of the page where the report reads as follows:
"Asked whether he would say the truth if he faces his
former chief Mr Blah said, 'I swear on the Bible I will say the
truth and nothing but the truth. I will not be there to testify
for or against, but answer whatever questions truthfully."
Can I pause there. Did you say that?
A. Yes.
Q. So can I take it then, former President, that you are not
here taking sides either for the Prosecution or the Defence. You
are here playing with a straight bat, straight down the middle,
concerned merely to tell the truth? Would that be a fair
assessment?
A. Yes, and that I have done.
Q. It continues in the penultimate paragraph on that page:
"In a subpoena testificandum dated March 7, 2008 with
reference number 155/2008, Mr Blah, a one time inspector general
of the defunct National Patriotic Front of Liberia, has been
ordered to appear voluntarily before the Special Court for Sierra
Leone next Monday April 14, 2008, at 9.30 am or show good cause
why he cannot comply with this subpoena. The subpoena placed in
the hands of Mr Blah said any willful failure on the part of the
former President constitutes contempt of the Special Court
pursuant to Rule 77 of the rules. The subpoena: 'Should you
fail to comply the Trial Chamber may deal with the matter
summarily itself, refer the matter to the appropriate authorities
of Sierra Leone , or if there are sufficient grounds to proceed
against you for contempt issue an order in lieu of an indictment
and direct independent counsel to prosecute the matter.'"
The subpoena states, adding:
"If you are convicted for contempt of the Special Court you
may be imprisoned for up to 7 years or fined up to 2 million
leones or both."
CONTINUE ON NEXT PAGE